Archive for May, 2007

Mesh Keynote #2: Austin Hill & Tom Williams

The second keynote of the day is focusing on “The Web and Philanthropy” with Austin Hill and Tom Williams. Austin is not wearing his hat.
Both Tom and Austin are long, long time Internet entrepreneurs and both are now working on start ups with goals of using technology and the Internet for ’something more’.

Tom – “My father told me that I was more famous for being famous then for doing anything.” He was a living the good life, until he was visited by a friend from way back who told him that he was full of it. He was 21. Decided that he would be someone who would facilitate connections between people who are passionate about doing something.

Austin – “Missionary entrepreneurs” Started with a social mission during the first boom. Radial Point was very profitable. Was shaken by the death of his 19 year old brother of cancer. Set up a foundation to help raise money for cancer research. Someone advised him to “Celebrate his brother’s life instead of mourning his death.” Stepped away from Radial Point to help others change the world. “We are beginning to play in the real world.”

Tom – Causal mindedness is all in us. We can get something concrete by helping other people. He had to sit through a lot of meaningless meetings in Web1.0.

Austin – Was working in privacy issues in Web1.0 and saw activism online since the beginning. “The broadband Hierarchy of Needs” – Access, privacy/security, connections with other people. “I have the ability to be who I believe I am.” We are providing the tools.

Tom – The establishment need to let go of it’s control to maintain relevance. Applies to charities as well.

Austin – Social change online is still in it’s infancy. Trees for Life plants real trees and matches it to a tree online. Make it fun to get more people involved.

Tom – Internet anonymity allows people to be disconnected from groups they join. -Causes flame wars and bad behaviour that prevents groups from growing beyond very specific niches. As givemeaning grew the participation rates dropped. They grew as a good news community. Struggle to find their own meaning. Students went to Ecuador mountain and live blogged about what they found there on givemeaning.

Austin – Disconnect of what people say and what they do. With new social media tech, ideas can be put into action quickly. Daily.

Tom – Return on generosity – too much focus on the “Ask” instead of what is done/the results.

Q&A Section

Q: How do we bridge the digital divide?

Tom – Road to hell is paved with good intentions. Obsessed with the solution before we understand the problem. Opening up the conversation. “Do I want to be part of the conversation or do I just want to promote my solution?”

Q: Bullying online

Austin – Myspace was a success because it allowed teens to talk about music, yell at each other and brag – what more do teens want? Empowering kids to feel that they are empowered to make a difference. They will make mistakes.

Q: Why does taking payment change everything?

Tom – People are cynical about being solicited to take money. Charities being about raising money instead of doing good works.

Other notes:

Austin – Wikipedia: lots of small changes can have a big effect. Dark Green PC, turn off screensavers, power down and save power. Open Source and if it was 100 million PCs, could power Switzerland for 1 year.

Austin – David Bornstein – “How to Change the World” – read it.  Capitalism can be a tool for social change.  Social Entrepreneurship.  Make meaning and money will flow from that.

You can check out the official Mesh post here.

Live from Mesh – The Michael Arrington Keynote

Reporting live from Mesh Conference 2007:

9:38 Mesh is a little bit different in that the keynotes are conversational rather than having someone stand up and simply make a speech. Today’s first conversation is with Michael Arrington of Techcrunch.

Notes (all paraphrased):

Arrington was apparently reading 400 or 500 feeds when he started TC.

“Techcrunch France is the biggest blog in France”

“Techcrunch France is largely run from Tel Aviv”

“The best content is in the comments”

“I like rattling people and I can be rattled”

Arrington sometime deletes/edits comments that he regrets later or if things get out of hand. “Occasionally”

“I still don’t even know what a journalist is” On reporting: “If you’re first you don’t have to intelligent, witty, or insightful.”

Blogs are beating the newspapers because they are fast and they have the readers/blogosphere as fact-checkers.

“Journalists should leave the papers because they will make more money without them”

It’s opened up to the Q&A from the floor.

“Hopefully the downturn will happen in the next couple of years because it will be a lot more fun in the Valley” Too many PR and marketers are in the valley right now.

“I would have reported the Apple news about the iPhone delay.” “Engadget shouldn’t have lost credibility over this. It was Apple’s PR fault.”

If Arrington was running a newspaper: “IF it was NYT or WSJ, I would probably stop printing the newspaper and just run it online and make everything freely available. They don’t understand how much traffic they could get from having search engine indexed archives.”

“I think the next step in social networking is virtual reality.”

The people who run MySpace have no idea what they are doing. They might not be here to stay. Facebook is here to stay.

“If I say outrageous things, I make more money”

Techcrunch and Ted Murphy from PayPerPost just went head to head. Arrington “You probably only read our posts on Techcrunch where we trash you, so you probably don’t have any idea what we do.”

“I really believe my opinions are no more valid than any other… I go off on startups who are polluting/making society worse”

“We’re diversifying and we could go years without any revenue at all.”

“Facebook is probably the fastest growing photo site out there.”

The inevitable “How do I get my startup on Techcrunch?” “The best way to get me to write about something is for no one to have written about it before and the product really has to be good. There has to be a hook. It’s going to be hard for me to write about another me too product.” “I’ll never not write about something if I don’t get an exclusive. The problem is that people aren’t honouring embargoes. If the embargo is blown by someone else, I won’t write about it at all. I’m trying to bring some sanity back to the PR system.”

“Blog about what you love and you’ll be better at it.”

“Video and audio is a lot harder to make and consume. So right now Techcrunch will stick to text. I’m a writer that’s what I love to do.”

“I hired Heather because she is a steady ship. She’s brought a level of calmness to Techcrunch.”

Mesh’s official post on the keynote has been added here.

Find me at Mesh

This Wednesday and Thursday I will be at the Mesh Conference in Toronto. If you’re attending and want to meet up, send me an email or leave a comment.
I’m considering doing a live blog of the event, but we shall see. :)